top of page
Search

Dry Needling vs Acupuncture: What's the Difference?

Writer: Mick Breen
Mick Breen
Nov 13
5 min read

"Is dry needling the same as acupuncture?"


It's one of the most common questions I get at the clinic in Thornbury. Fair enough too. From the outside they look exactly the same. Someone lies on a table and a practitioner puts thin needles in them.


But they're doing two very different jobs. I'm a myotherapist, and dry needling is the tool I use more than anything else. Here's how it actually works, what it feels like and who it's for.


The Short Answer


Same needles. Different target.


Acupuncture comes from traditional Chinese medicine. It works with pressure points, meridians and channels around the body. Those points can be anywhere, including the head, face and feet, and the needles usually sit quite shallow.


Dry needling goes after trigger points. These are tight, tender knots inside a muscle, and they can turn up anywhere in that muscle. So the needle goes into the muscle itself, wherever that trigger point is sitting.


To be upfront, I'm not an acupuncturist. I've only had acupuncture once myself, so I'm not going to tell you how well it works or when you should see one. What I do know is muscles. That's what dry needling is built for.


How Dry Needling Actually Works


Depending on the muscle, how big it is and where it is in the body, the needle can go anywhere from 10 or 15 mm deep in a small muscle, right up to 100 mm in a big one like the glutes.


The aim is to hit that trigger point and get it to let go. That does a few things:

  • it calms down the tension in the muscle

  • it brings blood flow back into the area

  • it sends a new signal from the brain to the muscle, basically saying "Hey, there's too much tension here. Let's change it."


A lot of people think needling breaks the muscle down. It doesn't. It changes the signal, gets the blood moving and lets the tension go.


Why I wiggle the needle


I'm a little bit different here. I don't put a needle in and walk away. Honestly, I don't like practitioners who do that. It's kind of lazy needling.


Instead I come back and give the needle a little wiggle, here and there, to get as many twitches out of the muscle as I can. The more twitches we get, the more tension we let go of. Yes, it's a bit more uncomfortable. But we get there quicker, and you feel the result then and there.


Sometimes a needle is in for 20 seconds. Sometimes it's a couple of minutes. It depends on what that muscle is doing.


What Does Dry Needling Feel Like?


It can be a little bit uncomfortable. It's not the most painful thing in the world, not at all.

The part people notice most is the twitch response. It's a quick little spasm in the muscle, and it can be big or small depending on the muscle. Around the traps it's very common. Around the head it feels a bit weird. In the bigger muscles the twitch is bigger. But a twitch just means we've hit the right spot.


The soreness afterwards


The biggest downside of needling is the ache afterwards. It feels like you've just done a hard leg or shoulder workout at the gym.


That soreness can go in anywhere from a couple of hours to a couple of days. It depends on how tight you've been and how long it's been since your last treatment. The first treatment is always the worst, unfortunately. But that just shows you how much your body needed it. I've written more about whether it's normal to feel sore after dry needling if you want the detail.


Nervous About Needles? That's Completely Normal


Who wants a needle stuck in them?? A lot of people are nervous, and that's very normal.

So I always say, "Look, we don't have to do it." I'll explain why I think needling gives you a better result. It's a little bit of discomfort for a much better outcome. But if you don't want to, that's cool. There's plenty we can do with massage, cupping and trigger point work instead. And if you give it a go and don't like it, we'll change it up.


I've had several clients with a real phobia of needles get past it, just by trusting me and giving it a go. Once they see the results, the fear pretty much goes. Most of them still don't want to look at the needles, which is more than fine. Why would you?


What Dry Needling Helps With


Dry needling suits most people with tight muscles, pain or an injury, especially if you want relief quickly. Because you can needle pretty much any muscle in the body, it helps with a lot.

The 3 I see most at the clinic are:

  • Headaches. A lot of tension headaches come from the traps and shoulders. Needling there can really calm the headache tension down. More on that on my headache treatment page.

  • Tennis elbow. The forearms need a lot of work, and needling is the quickest way into them. Here's how I treat tennis elbow.

  • Lower back pain. Needling is the best way I know to get deep into the glutes and around the hips, which is often where the back tension is really coming from.


The best result I've ever had


One of my clients came in with severe, chronic migraines. They came every fortnight like clockwork and knocked her out for 24 to 48 hours. She was pretty nervous about needles, but her husband insisted she come in.


She was a high-powered lawyer with a very stressful job, walking around in high heels all day, and all of that stress was sitting in her traps. They felt like absolute concrete. That first session was tough. Getting the needles in hurt, because that tension had been stuck there for so long.


A week later she came back. She'd had one tiny headache that week. Her words to me were that she had her "pre-migraine life back". Honestly, that's the best feeling ever, and it's exactly why I do this.


Not everyone responds that fast. But it shows what can happen when you go straight to the muscle that's holding the problem.


Who Should Be Careful With Dry Needling


Dry needling is safe for most people, but there are a few situations where I either go carefully or use something else. Tell me before your session if any of these apply to you:

  • You're on blood thinners or have a bleeding disorder. It's not an automatic no, but I need to know so we can decide together.

  • You're pregnant, especially in the first trimester. I'll use other techniques instead.

  • You have lymphoedema, or have had lymph nodes removed. I'll stay away from those areas.

  • You have broken skin or an infection over the area, or you're unwell. We'll wait or work around it.


And if you really don't want needles, that's fine too. You'll still get a great treatment.


How Many Sessions Will You Need?


It's hard to say before I've assessed you. But as a guide, plan on at least 3 sessions in the first couple of weeks to get on top of things. After that we push it out to every 2 weeks, then every 4 weeks.


How quickly you get there depends a lot on you. Doing your exercises, your rehab and using what I've shown you makes a big difference.


Does Dry Needling Cost Extra?


No. Dry needling is included in your treatment at my clinic. I don't charge extra for it, and I don't need to. I mix it in with massage and cupping, depending on what your body needs on the day.


Book Dry Needling in Thornbury


If it's muscle or soft tissue pain, in my opinion that's what someone like me is there for. I'm based at 3/8 Theobald St, Thornbury, with free parking, and you can claim on the spot with HICAPS.


New clients get $10 off their first treatment. Grab it on my new client offer page, or read more about dry needling in Thornbury.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page